Siding Compare

Consumer Reviews of Goodfellow Wood Siding

33% of Customers Recommend
2 of 5 stars 3 reviews
  • Very Satisfied
  • Somewhat Satisfied
  • Neutral
  • Somewhat Unsatisfied
  • Very Unsatisfied

The opinions expressed in these reviews are the opinions of consumers that submitted reviews to They do not necessarily represent the opinions of

Read reviews of other Wood Siding brandsWrite a review

Review Written: 2020-09-15

Goodfellow Review: "Knot holes lost colour"

Name: P Smith
Location: Parry Sound ON

Wood Siding Satisfaction Rating:
1 of 5 stars Very Unsatisfied

Do not use this product. I have now read other reviews and this is a common problem with this company. We built our cottage 7 years ago and all the knot holes lost their colour. I dealt with Steeve Dirago from the warranty department. He made me send all kinds of pictures and fill out a 5 page report. Only to say they will not honour the 25 year warranty. Please save yourself a lot of money. I am now having my siding stained after 7 years. I wish I could include pictures, if you saw them you would say clear of this company.

Review Written: 2012-05-09

Goodfellow Review: "What crap"

Name: lou colubrial
Location: montreal, quebec

Wood Siding Satisfaction Rating:
1 of 5 stars Very Unsatisfied

I would definately not recommend this outdoor wood siding product to anybody in Quebec. I had the front of my house re-done with this wood. $15,000 installed a year and half ago. The wood-siding was installed in the fall Sept 2010. By the spring it was already faded. The summer 2011 wood faded ever more and when it would rain it would look like the wood was absorbing the water. The maufacturer guarantees the product will not fade for at least min 5years. The wood rotted and i feel like removing each plank off personally and smashing against the heads of my contractor and the producers of this product. I spoke to the contractor who installed this crap to come take a look and he tells me that lots of people have been complaining.

Review Written: 2011-02-21

Goodfellow Review: "I like my wood siding."

Location: Tampa, FL

Wood Siding Satisfaction Rating:
4 of 5 stars Somewhat Satisfied

I owned my wood siding for over 15 years. It's been through storms, hail, and sun abuse. It still looks great. I love the natural wood color and stain. It was the easiest thing to upgrade on my house. The wood siding went up in a jiffy. I don't like that the maintenance is painstaking to keep it looking new. I also dislike, that you just cant clean it with just any product. I had some water damage to the siding one year, from a water break. I had to replace it with the same Goodfellow Tradition siding. I have not did anything else to it. I would recommend that brand to anyone.